Pick the rowing machine if you are healthy and want your legs, back and arms to work in one session; it also cost slightly more energy than a recumbent bike at a very hard effort in a lab study of 30 men. Pick the recumbent exercise bike if you want back support, no technique to learn and an easy return to exercise.
The recumbent exercise bike vs rowing machine choice comes down to what you want the machine to do for your body. A recumbent bike works your legs from a seat with a backrest. A rowing machine works your legs, trunk and arms in one stroke on a sliding seat, and you have to learn that stroke. I compared the two on muscle work, energy cost, back and rib injuries, heart response and floor space.
Our rowing machine lineup covers current models across resistance types if rowing turns out to be the better fit for you.
Recumbent Exercise Bike vs Rowing Machine - A Side-by-Side Overview
The recumbent exercise bike vs rowing machine comparison starts with what each machine asks your body to do. A recumbent bike seats you low with a backrest behind you and the pedals out in front, so your legs push forward while the seat carries your trunk. A rowing machine puts you on a sliding seat with your feet strapped to a footboard. You push with your legs, swing your trunk back, then draw the handle to your body, and reverse that order to return.
You can browse current recumbent bikes for sale in our shop while you weigh the two formats.
One lab study measured both machines in the same people: 30 fit, experienced men in their early 40s worked for 12 minutes on each of seven indoor machines, including a recumbent bike and a Concept2 RowErg, at the same very hard effort (1).
| Feature | Recumbent Exercise Bike | Rowing Machine |
|---|---|---|
| Muscles doing the work | Thighs, hips and calves | Legs, trunk and arms in one stroke |
| Upper body | Arms rest on the handles | Back and arms pull the handle |
| Energy at a very hard effort (30 men) | 11.1 kcal per minute | 11.5 kcal per minute |
| Technique to learn | Little: sit and pedal | A stroke sequence to learn |
| Back support | Backrest carries the trunk | None: your trunk holds itself |
| Length (example models) | 64 to 66.4 in (Schwinn 230, 290) | 8 ft; 9 x 4 ft in use (Concept2 RowErg) |
| My pick for | A supported, easy start | Back and arm work with your cardio |
They are also the starting point for choosing the best recumbent exercise bike for a home gym, since recumbent models differ in resistance type, seat design and console.
Muscle Activation - Full-Body Engagement vs Lower-Body Focus
Here the recumbent exercise bike vs rowing machine comparison splits most clearly. A 2016 study recorded muscle activity in 12 recreationally active adults for 2 minutes on each of four machines, an upright bike, a recumbent bike, a treadmill and an ElliptiGO, at a moderate effort of 40 to 50% of heart rate reserve (2). On the recumbent bike the front-thigh muscle (rectus femoris) worked less than on the ElliptiGO, and the calf worked less than on the upright bike. The glutes, a hamstring, lower-back muscles and abdominals worked at similar, low to moderate levels on all four machines.

Rowing spreads the work across more of the body. In nine internationally competitive rowers, muscle activity was recorded in the upper trapezius, latissimus dorsi, biceps, three front-thigh muscles, a hamstring and the shin muscle during a 1,000 m race on an ergometer and on the water, and most of these muscles were more active on the ergometer (3). A second study recorded 23 muscles in eight untrained people and seven experienced rowers on an ergometer: 22 of the 23 grew more active as power rose (4). These studies show which muscles work, not how much muscle a home rower builds.
Rowing Machine - Muscles by Stroke Phase Contribution
- Drive, legs first: the thigh muscles straighten the knees and push the seat back while the arms stay straight
- Drive, then trunk and arms: the back swings through upright, then the back and arm muscles (latissimus dorsi, trapezius, biceps) draw the handle in
- Recovery: the arms extend, the body leans forward from the hips, then the knees bend as the seat slides forward
Recumbent Bike - Primary Muscles Worked
- Quadriceps (front of thigh): straighten the knee on each push
- Hamstrings (back of thigh): low to moderate activity in the 2016 study
- Gluteus maximus and medius: low to moderate, similar on the upright and recumbent bike
- Calves (gastrocnemius): less active than on an upright bike
- Trunk and arms: lower-back and abdominal muscles low to moderate; the arms only hold the handles
Concept2 tells new rowers not to pull hard until the technique basics feel comfortable (5). The plainest difference: the rower adds pulling work for the back and arms, and the recumbent bike does not. That is no weakness if you want leg work with your trunk supported.
If knee pain is part of your decision, the guide to exercise bike and knee pain covers bike setup and the warning signs to stop.
The page on muscles an exercise bike works goes further into the leg muscles of cycling.
Calorie Burn - Which Machine Generates More Calories Per Hour
In the recumbent exercise bike vs rowing machine comparison, the measured calorie gap is small. In the 30-man study, at a very hard effort (17 on the 6 to 20 perceived-exertion scale) the rowing machine cost 11.5 kcal per minute and the recumbent bike 11.1: about 0.4 kcal a minute, statistically significant but small. At all-out effort the two were almost level, 13.5 against 13.3, and the authors found no significant difference (1). Of the seven machines, the recumbent bike used the least energy and the rower the second least, each on one model.
For harder bike sessions, the guide to HIIT on exercise bike covers interval formats and resistance settings.
Reading the calorie figure on the console as a measurement. It is an estimate, and a resistance level on a bike is not a watt value.
People often ask how many minutes on a recumbent bike equals 10,000 steps. No conversion exists, because a bike counts no steps. Count minutes instead: US guidelines ask adults for at least 150 to 300 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity a week (6), and moderate minutes on either machine count toward that.
The table below uses the 2024 Adult Compendium of Physical Activities, which lists stationary cycling and stationary rowing by power output in watts (7). It has no separate entry for a recumbent bike, so the bike column uses the stationary cycling entries. Each cell is an estimate for a 155 lb (70 kg) adult over 30 minutes: METs x 70 kg x 0.5 hours, rounded to the nearest 10 kcal.
| Power on the display | Stationary bike, about kcal in 30 min | Rowing machine, about kcal in 30 min |
|---|---|---|
| Under 100 W | 140 (50 W) to 210 (90-100 W) | 180 (one entry for all of it) |
| 100 to 149 W | 240 (101-125 W) to 280 (126-150 W) | 260 |
| 150 to 199 W | 360 | 390 |
Estimates, not measurements, on the basis above. Only the 150 to 199 W bands match on both machines, and there the rower is a little higher. A resistance level on a bike console is not a watt figure, so use this table only if your machine shows watts.
At the same power output, rowing costs more energy than cycling. In 60 men and 47 women aged 20 to 74, oxygen use and heart rate were higher at every power step of a rowing test than at the same power on a cycle ergometer (8). The bike in that study was a lab cycle ergometer, not specifically a recumbent. In my view, the machine that burns more in your home is the one you work harder on and stay on longer.
For a structured plan on the bike, the cycling workout plan to lose weight sets out steady and interval sessions.
The cycling vs rowing comparison covers the same question for upright cycling.
If weight loss is your main aim, read the page on the rowing machine good for weight loss question before you buy.
When choosing the best exercise bike for home use, how long you can sit comfortably on it matters as much as its calorie figures.
Joint Impact - How Each Machine Loads Your Body
Both machines are low-impact cardio: neither has the foot strike of running or jumping. With joint pain or a recent operation, check with your doctor or physical therapist before you choose. For more low-impact options, the guide to the best machines for bad knees compares other machine types.

A recumbent bike's backrest carries your trunk, so you need no technique to hold your posture. That is a design point, not a measured result: none of the studies cited here measured spinal or knee load on a recumbent bike against a rowing machine.
On a rowing machine your trunk is unsupported, and the lower back is one of the sites where competitive rowers most often get hurt. A 2012 review found rowing injuries mostly overuse injuries of the knee, lumbar spine and ribs, tied to training volume and technique (9). Among 76 international-level rowers in New Zealand followed for 12 months, 40 (53%) reported at least one episode of low back pain, and new episodes were closely correlated with monthly training hours (10), but a 2025 meta-analysis of 10 studies (2,082 rowers) found no significant link with training volume, so the evidence is mixed (11). A 2021 review of 22 studies found that fatigue increases how far the lower back bends forward at the catch, more so on an ergometer than on the water (12). These are competitive rowers, so the figures are not a risk estimate for a home rower.
On a rower, push with the legs first and pull with the arms last. When your form slips late in a session, stop.
Ribs are the other site to know about: over four years, 19 rib stress injuries (12 bone stress reactions and 7 fractures) were recorded among 151 athletes of the Australian Rowing Team (13). That, too, is an elite squad. At home, keep sessions short while you learn the stroke, stop when your form breaks down, and have new back or rib pain checked by a doctor or physical therapist.
The question is rowing bad for your back gets a full answer in its own guide, with the form errors to avoid.
If you are new to rowing, the guide to rowing machines for beginners looks at models suited to a first rower.
When the recumbent bike is the easier starting point (check with your doctor or physical therapist first):
- Back pain that flares when you sit without a backrest
- A past knee or hip operation, once your surgeon or physical therapist has cleared cycling
- Poor balance: you sit in a fixed seat with a backrest instead of sliding on a rail
- Trouble getting down to a seat near the floor and back up
For the best exercise bike for back problems, I would look at a recumbent first, because the backrest supports the trunk. That is my judgement from the design, not a treatment; a physical therapist who knows your back can confirm it.
If you have osteoporosis and are considering rowing, the guide on a rowing machine for osteoporosis covers the questions to settle with your doctor.
The recumbent bike vs upright comparison weighs the same backrest question between the two bike types.
The guide to stationary bike types and differences explains how the main bike types differ.
Cardiovascular Benefits - What the Research Tells Us
Both machines train your heart and lungs. One small direct comparison found a difference in how the heart responds: in 10 healthy men who rowed and cycled for 2 minutes each at the same power for their body weight (2 W per kg), heart rate and blood pressure were similar after both, but stroke volume (the blood pumped per beat) and cardiac output were higher after rowing (14). That was one short bout, not a training study, and the paper does not describe its bike as recumbent. The rowing machine benefits breakdown covers rowing's wider effects.
For the recumbent bike, the best-known comparison is with an upright bike, not a rower. In 14 men with coronary artery disease (average age 60), the same 100 W load raised heart rate, systolic blood pressure, oxygen use and perceived effort more on an upright bike than on a recumbent; at peak effort the two did not differ (15).
If you are healthy and want your back and arms to work along with your heart, the rower gives you that. With a heart condition, neither study tells you which machine is safer: your cardiologist or cardiac rehabilitation team sets the machine and the effort.
Key cardiovascular points:
- After a short bout at the same power, rowing raised the blood pumped per beat more than cycling did, in 10 healthy men
- At the same 100 W load, a recumbent bike raised heart rate less than an upright bike, in 14 men with coronary artery disease
- Moderate minutes on either machine count toward the weekly 150 to 300 minutes adults need
- With heart disease, chest pain or a recent heart procedure, talk with your doctor before you start either machine
If you are building a low-impact home gym, the best folding treadmill guide covers walking and running machines that fold away.
The guide on why exercise bikes are good for weight management looks at what regular cycling does for weight.
Who Should Choose the Recumbent Exercise Bike vs. the Rowing Machine
In my view, the recumbent bike vs rowing machine choice is simple: the recumbent bike removes barriers, and the rowing machine asks more of you and works more of you. The guide on muscles a rowing machine works goes deeper into the rowing stroke.

Choose a recumbent exercise bike if you:
- Have back, hip or knee problems and your doctor or physical therapist has cleared cycling
- Are returning to exercise after an injury or a long break and want a seat with a backrest
- Are an older adult who wants a seated machine with no stroke to learn
- Want to read or watch something while you exercise
- Have less floor length: the Schwinn 230 and 290 recumbents are 64 and 66.4 in long (16), against 8 ft for a Concept2 RowErg (17)
- Prefer to start without learning a new technique
- Have Parkinson's disease and want the fast, light-resistance pedaling studied on a recumbent bike, agreed with your neurologist or physical therapist
Choose a rowing machine if you:
- Want your back and arms to work along with your legs and heart
- Are healthy and want a machine that asks more of you at the same power
- Have no current back or rib pain and will take time to learn the stroke
- Have about 9 by 4 ft of clear floor for a Concept2 RowErg in use
- Enjoy hard interval sessions
- Already train for strength and want cardio that also uses your upper body
Parkinson's Disease - A Critical Evidence-Based Note
For people with Parkinson's disease, the evidence here is one-sided: the trial used a recumbent bike. Fourteen people with Parkinson's disease (Hoehn-Yahr stage 3.0 or lower) pedaled a recumbent bike at the lowest resistance under supervision, twice a week for six weeks: 12 sessions of 30 minutes, each with 20 fast 15-second bursts. Motor scores, walking speed, balance and stepping tests, hand dexterity and reaction time all improved (18). The study had no control group, so it cannot separate the training effect from other changes.
None of the studies cited here compared rowing with recumbent cycling in Parkinson's disease, so this is not evidence against rowing. Set up any program with your neurologist or a physical therapist who knows the condition.
If a folding bike is on your shortlist, the post on whether folding exercise bikes are a practical home training tool weighs stability against storage.
The page on what the erg machine actually is explains how a rowing ergometer works.
If you are new to the machine, the explainer on what a recumbent exercise bike is describes the seat, backrest and pedal position.
Heart Failure Considerations
With heart failure, the choice between rowing and a recumbent bike is not one to make alone, and none of the studies cited here compared the two machines in people with heart failure. Talk with your provider before you start, and ask before you move to a harder activity (19). Contact your provider if you feel pain, pressure, tightness or heaviness in the chest, arm, neck or jaw, shortness of breath, or lightheadedness, and right away if these symptoms are very bad or do not go away when you stop the activity (19). Exercise bikes for seniors is the guide to read if getting on and off a bike or your balance is a concern.
The table below is my judgement from the design of each machine and the studies above, not a medical recommendation.
| User Profile | Recommended Machine | Primary Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Chronic lower back pain | Recumbent bike, after a check with your doctor or physical therapist | Backrest supports the trunk; no stroke to learn |
| Seniors (65+) | Recumbent bike | Seated with a backrest; easy to start |
| Parkinson's disease | Recumbent bike, with your care team | The only one of the two tested in a small trial |
| Beginners | Recumbent bike | No stroke to learn |
| Athletes or advanced exercisers | Rowing machine | Legs, trunk and arms in one stroke |
| Time-limited exercisers | Rowing machine | Legs, trunk and arms in the same minutes |
| Apartment or small-space users | Recumbent bike | Shorter in use: 64 to 66.4 in against 96 in; the RowErg splits in two for storage |
| Heart failure | Your cardiology team decides | Not compared in the studies cited here |
Choosing the Right Machine for Your Fitness Goals
The recumbent exercise bike vs rowing machine comparison ends with one practical question: which machine will you use week after week? In my view, a gentler machine you use most days does more than a harder one you avoid. For most people coming back to cardio I would start with the recumbent bike, because nothing about it has to be learned.
- STEP 1Check with your clinician With back, knee, hip or heart problems, ask your doctor or physical therapist which machine suits you.
- STEP 2Name your goal Back and arm work points to the rower; a supported, easy start points to the recumbent bike.
- STEP 3Measure the floor A Concept2 RowErg needs about 9 by 4 ft in use; a Schwinn 290 recumbent is 66.4 in long.
- STEP 4Start easy Begin at an effort where you can still talk, and add time before you add resistance.
If you settle on the bike, the guide to calories burned on a stationary bike explains how body weight, effort and time change the figure.
If you cannot decide, combination machines exist, such as the Stamina Conversion II Recumbent Bike. Check its product page for which motions it offers before you count on rowing from it.
Resistance type affects noise and upkeep; the guide on how a magnetic exercise bike works explains the mechanism.
If the rower is your choice, the post on whether a rowing machine suits your home works through space and skill.
If the recumbent bike is the right direction, the guide on choosing an exercise bike walks through resistance type and seat setup.
The guide on what a stationary bike costs explains what drives the cost of each bike type.
If you track activity on the bike, the ankle-mounted fitness tracker guide looks at trackers worn on the ankle.
For those who choose rowing, our guide on how to use a rowing machine correctly covers the technique basics.
If budget is tight, the guide to the top budget rowing machines covers lower-cost rowers.
Compact folding exercise bikes are the other format to consider if you lean toward the bike and floor space is tight.
A rower is long, so plan its spot first; the treadmill disassembly and equipment-handling guide covers moving heavy home gym equipment safely.
For those curious about how a magnetic resistance exercise bike works: it uses magnets rather than a friction pad to slow the flywheel.
If you choose rowing and want that kind of resistance, the magnetic rowing machine guide covers rowers that use it.
Belly fat is a common goal on either machine; the page on exercise bike fat loss research explains what cycling studies measured.
The exercise bike transformation timeline guide looks at what changes, and when, with regular riding.
Heart rate is one way to set effort on either machine; the guide on heart rate zones for stationary cycling explains the zones.
If rowing is your pick, the best rowing machine guide compares current rowers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, a rowing machine or a recumbent bike?
It depends on your goal and your body. A rowing machine works the legs, trunk and arms, while a recumbent exercise bike supports your back and needs no technique, so the recumbent exercise bike vs rowing machine choice usually comes down to which one you will keep using.
How many minutes on a recumbent bike equals 10,000 steps?
There is no exact conversion, because a bike records no steps and the effort per minute depends on resistance and cadence. Compare time at a similar effort instead: pedal at the effort of a brisk walk for as long as the walk would last.
What is the best exercise bike for Parkinson’s disease?
Of these two machines, only the recumbent bike has a trial in Parkinson's disease, where fast pedaling at the lowest resistance improved motor scores, walking and balance tests in a small six-week study without a control group. Plan the program with your neurologist or a physical therapist.
Is rowing good for heart failure?
Only your cardiologist or cardiac rehabilitation team can say whether rowing fits your heart failure care, and the studies cited on this page did not compare the two machines in heart failure. Talk with your provider before you start, and stop and contact them if you feel chest pain or pressure, shortness of breath or lightheadedness.
Tech Fitness LabAuthor
Vanja Vukas
I founded Tech Fitness Lab and hold a master's degree from the Faculty of Sport and Physical Education in Novi Sad. I have competed in sport and coached clients, and my writing has appeared on Fitness Volt and BOXROX. I research products from their manuals, spec sheets and warranty terms, and I flag thin evidence.
References
- Prieto-González P, Yagin FH. Energy expenditure, oxygen consumption, and heart rate while exercising on seven different indoor cardio machines at maximum and self-selected submaximal intensity. Front Sports Act Living. 2024;6:1313886. doi:10.3389/fspor.2024.1313886.
- Bouillon L, Baker R, Gibson C, Kearney A, Busemeyer T. Comparison of trunk and lower extremity muscle activity among four stationary equipment devices: upright bike, recumbent bike, treadmill, and ElliptiGO. Int J Sports Phys Ther. 2016;11(2):190-200.
- Bazzucchi I, Sbriccoli P, Nicolò A, et al. Cardio-respiratory and electromyographic responses to ergometer and on-water rowing in elite rowers. Eur J Appl Physiol. 2013;113(5):1271-1277. doi:10.1007/s00421-012-2550-2.
- Turpin NA, Guével A, Durand S, Hug F. Effect of power output on muscle coordination during rowing. Eur J Appl Physiol. 2011;111(12):3017-3029. doi:10.1007/s00421-011-1928-x.
- Concept2. Rowing technique. Concept2. Accessed November 20, 2026.
- Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. Top 10 things to know about the second edition of the Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans. US Department of Health and Human Services. Accessed November 20, 2026.
- Herrmann SD, Willis EA, Ainsworth BE, et al. 2024 Adult Compendium of Physical Activities: a third update of the energy costs of human activities. J Sport Health Sci. 2024;13(1):6-12. doi:10.1016/j.jshs.2023.10.010.
- Hagerman FC, Lawrence RA, Mansfield MC. A comparison of energy expenditure during rowing and cycling ergometry. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1988;20(5):479-488. doi:10.1249/00005768-198810000-00009.
- Hosea TM, Hannafin JA. Rowing injuries. Sports Health. 2012;4(3):236-245. doi:10.1177/1941738112442484.
- Newlands C, Reid D, Parmar P. The prevalence, incidence and severity of low back pain among international-level rowers. Br J Sports Med. 2015;49(14):951-956. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2014-093889.
- Ze X, Zhang S, Long X, Zhou P. Risk factors associated with low back pain in rowers: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Sports Sci Med Rehabil. 2025;17(1):157. doi:10.1186/s13102-025-01153-y.
- Nugent FJ, Vinther A, McGregor A, Thornton JS, Wilkie K, Wilson F. The relationship between rowing-related low back pain and rowing biomechanics: a systematic review. Br J Sports Med. 2021;55(11):616-628. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2020-102533.
- Harris R, Trease L, Wilkie K, Drew M. Rib stress injuries in the 2012-2016 (Rio) Olympiad: a cohort study of 151 Australian Rowing Team athletes for 88 773 athlete days. Br J Sports Med. 2020;54(16):991-996. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2019-101584.
- Horn P, Ostadal P, Ostadal B. Rowing increases stroke volume and cardiac output to a greater extent than cycling. Physiol Res. 2015;64(2):203-207. doi:10.33549/physiolres.932853.
- Bonzheim SC, Franklin BA, DeWitt C, et al. Physiologic responses to recumbent versus upright cycle ergometry, and implications for exercise prescription in patients with coronary artery disease. Am J Cardiol. 1992;69(1):40-44. doi:10.1016/0002-9149(92)90673-m.
- Schwinn Fitness. Compare bikes. Johnson Health Tech Trading. Accessed November 20, 2026.
- Concept2. Concept2 RowErg. Concept2. Accessed November 20, 2026.
- Uygur M, Bellumori M, Knight CA. Effects of a low-resistance, interval bicycling intervention in Parkinson's disease. Physiother Theory Pract. 2017;33(12):897-904. doi:10.1080/09593985.2017.1359868.
- MedlinePlus. Being active when you have heart disease. US National Library of Medicine. Reviewed August 5, 2024. Accessed November 20, 2026.

